The Evening PrimroseMelbourne ·
Southern sky / field notes

The Evening Primrose

Issue #01

37.8136° S144.9631° E—

Melbourne, Victoria

Fetching conditions
—°
Local conditions
Feels like —
—Cloud cover
—Wind km/h
—Humidity

Current conditions provided by Open-Meteo.

Southern sky

Calculating sky
E · EASTSOUTHWEST · WHORIZON

Positions are calculated for Melbourne and update with local time. Weather and light affect naked-eye visibility.

A lost mathematics of reading

Essay · Digan Gurung

The humanities—fields like literature, philosophy, and history—once commanded the same level of intellectual prestige, structural rigor, and institutional investment currently reserved for the hard sciences and engineering. There was once a coordinated, high-stakes intellectual apparatus dedicated to advancing human literacy and textual analysis, much like DARPA (the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, the U.S. Department of Defense agency known for high-risk, high-reward technological breakthroughs) or Operation Paperclip (the post-WWII U.S. intelligence program that relocated German scientists to America to preserve elite technical knowledge).

During this period, textual analysis operated much like algebra. In mathematics, variables are declared, defined, and manipulated across an equals sign to solve complex problems and prove objective truths. In this classical literary tradition, a qualia (a qualitative property, subjective experience, or internal quality of perception) rather than a quanta (a measurable, discrete quantity) served as the variable. Writers defined specific thematic or philosophical terms early in a text and manipulated them consistently to prove structural theorems. Just like a mathematical proof, I can verify these literary equations for objective validity, ensuring that the writer's intended communication (authorial communique) is transmitted without relying on modern subjective opinions or sentimental interpretations.

While critics often point to contemporary campus politics or culture wars as the source of the humanities' decline, I see this as a superficial distraction—like a familial squabble around a campfire between Lombards (the Germanic people who ruled Italy in the Early Middle Ages) beneath a vast Roman viaduct they neither built nor had a frame of reference for. In this analogy, the Roman infrastructure represents the monumental engineering of classical and Renaissance thought, while modern academia represents a population living among ruins they can no longer construct.

The fracture between the sciences and humanities

The structural foundations of advanced literary analysis collapsed during World War II, capping a decline that began in the late 17th century with the rise of pure empirical scientism and the split between what C.P. Snow famously termed the "two cultures" of science and the humanities [1]. If universities continue on this trajectory, it will be equivalent to humanity forgetting advanced mathematics, falling backward into basic arithmetic, and treating a single historical figure like Albert Einstein as an unapproachable myth three centuries from now.

Great works of literature have frequently employed deliberate encryption not to be obscure for its own sake, but because certain truths were deemed unsuited for mass, uncritical consumption—much like adult domestic affairs are shielded from young children. Political philosopher Leo Strauss analyzed this tradition in Persecution and the Art of Writing (1952), showing how thinkers facing censorship or public misunderstanding encode complex ideas beneath orthodox surfaces [2].

Reading encrypted works

To maintain a mature tradition, writers relied on veiled speech and multi-layered subplots. Because modern readers lack these traditional cryptographic keys and analytical tools, vast subtextual layers in classic literature remain undiscovered. This loss of synthetic, holistic thinking—contrasted with modern scientific specialization—acts as an ischemic stroke (a blockage of blood flow and oxygen) to our collective intellectual capacity, severely damaging half of human cognition.

Two forms of encryption

I categorize encrypted literature into two distinct types:

  1. Overtly Encrypted Works: Texts like John Milton’s Paradise Lost (1667) or James Joyce’s Ulysses (1922) intentionally signal their complex obfuscation and parallel subplots. In Paradise Lost (Book VII, lines 1–39), Milton explicitly states his goal of finding an audience that is "fit though few" (adapting Horace’s Odes III.1) [3], shielding profound ideas from being torn apart by public hostility—symbolically compared to Maenads, the frenzied female worshippers of Dionysus in Greek mythology who tore the poet Orpheus limb from limb [4].
  2. Covertly Encrypted Works: Texts like Ernest Hemingway’s The Old Man and the Sea (1952) conceal their structural layers so thoroughly that their underlying methodology goes unnoticed for decades.

Milton’s architecture

Milton did not merely write verse; he engineered Paradise Lost using strict numerological, geometric, and proportional architecture—a hallmark of Renaissance humanism where mathematics and poetics were unified [5]:

  • Tectonic Symmetry and the Golden Ratio: Scholars of Renaissance numerology (such as Alastair Fowler) have demonstrated that Milton structured the epic around exact line counts and proportional symmetry [6]. In the original 1667 ten-book edition (later expanded to twelve books in 1674 to mirror Virgil’s Aeneid), the exact mathematical midpoint of the poem’s line count falls precisely at the moment Christ ascends into the Chariot of Paternal Deity to defeat the rebel angels (Book VI)—placing divine order at the geometric center of the cosmos.
  • Geometric Cosmology: Milton maps the universe using Euclidean geometry and Ptolemaic/Copernican astronomy. Hell, Chaos, Earth, and Heaven are separated by strict spatial ratios. Satan’s journey through Chaos is described in terms of geometric coordinates, void, and gravitational equilibrium, turning theological states (grace vs. sin) into spatial vectors (ascent vs. descent).
  • Algebraic Variable Substitution: Milton treats classical myths and biblical typology as interchangeable variables. By equating pagan deities with fallen angels in Book I, he sets up an algebraic identity (Pagan Pantheon = Fallen Angels), allowing him to manipulate classical history as a subset of Christian theology throughout the rest of the epic.

Hemingway’s hidden equations

Published in 1952, The Old Man and the Sea won the Pulitzer Prize (1953) and catalyzed Hemingway’s Nobel Prize in Literature (1954) [7]. While mainstream criticism treats it as a simple parable of endurance, I view it as a covertly encrypted blueprint detailing the collapse of the humanities and functioning as a premonitory rationale for his suicide in 1961.

Early in the novella, Hemingway establishes an explicit algebraic declaration (Santiago = Christ) when the old fisherman injures his hands on the fishing line:

"Ay," he said aloud. There is no translation for this word and perhaps it is just a noise such as a man might make, involuntarily, feeling the nail go through his hands and into the wood [8].

From this anchor, Hemingway builds a precise system of substitutions:

  • Fishing = The writing process.
  • The Fish (Marlin) = Complex philosophical or literary ideas.
  • Other Fishermen = Contemporary rival writers (whose lines drift laterally in shallow water, whereas Hemingway drops his line vertically into deep "fathoms").
  • Havana = The polis (the general public).
  • Sharks = Critics and cultural decay that strip a masterpiece down to an unrecognizable skeleton before the public can comprehend it.

Midway through the subtext, Hemingway realizes he falls short of Christ’s redemptive permanence and shifts his self-identification to Judas Iscariot, the betrayer. Santiago wonders if the marlin's silver belly meat will fetch thirty cents per pound—echoing the thirty pieces of silver for which Judas betrayed Christ [9]. Santiago vows to dedicate the fish’s sword to Our Lady of Cobre (Cuba's patron saint), mirroring Hemingway’s real-world donation of his Nobel medal to the El Cobre shrine [10], before both Judas and Hemingway meet violent ends involving bodily rupture (referenced via Acts 1:18) [11]. Even when Hemingway claimed in private letters that "a shark is just a shark," he was protecting his Iceberg Theory—the principle that seven-eighths of a story’s meaning must remain submerged beneath the surface to preserve its structural power [12].

From myth to political theatre

This symbolic-algebraic methodology extends directly into ancient and early modern governance. Early epics like Jason and the Argonauts functioned as encrypted manuals for statecraft [13]: when Jason throws a stone among the warring Spartoi (warriors sprung from dragon’s teeth) so they fight one another instead of him, the myth encodes a civic principle—channeling destructive martial energy (Ares) into institutionalized competition (such as public athletics) to preserve a stable, agrarian state. Similarly, in Homer’s Odyssey, geographic obstacles across the Mediterranean operate as a spatial map of the human psyche.

This tradition reaches its political zenith in William Shakespeare. Rather than acting merely as a popular entertainer, Shakespeare operated at the intersection of theater, intelligence, and Tudor-Stuart statecraft [14]:

  • Theater as a Political Simulator: In Elizabethan and Jacobean England, open political dissent meant treason and execution. Shakespeare used historical settings (ancient Rome in Julius Caesar and Coriolanus, medieval Scotland in Macbeth, Denmark in Hamlet) as algebraic variables to model real-time succession crises, surveillance states, and the psychology of tyranny without triggering royal censorship.
  • Patronage and the State Apparatus: Shakespeare’s acting company, the Lord Chamberlain’s Men (later the King’s Men under James I), was directly sponsored by the highest levels of the English Privy Council—the same officials who ran England’s espionage networks [15]. Plays like Macbeth (written shortly after the Gunpowder Plot of 1605) actively engaged with King James I’s political treatises on divine right and witchcraft, functioning as sophisticated instruments of civic stabilization and anti-memetic statecraft [16].

Analysis and synthesis

To understand why modern academia can no longer read these encrypted structures, I turn to Immanuel Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason (1781), which defines the two fundamental operations of human cognition: analysis and synthesis [17].

  • Analysis (Breaking Apart): An analytic judgment takes a concept and dissects it into its constituent parts without adding new information (e.g., "All bachelors are unmarried"). Modern science and contemporary humanities specialization rely almost exclusively on analysis—isolating variables, hyper-specializing in narrow sub-fields, and breaking texts down into isolated fragments of race, class, or gender.
  • Synthesis (Bringing Together): A synthetic judgment connects distinct, separate concepts to generate a unified whole and produce new knowledge (e.g., "Every event has a cause" or uniting geometric space with algebraic proof). For Kant, synthesis is the primary act of the imagination and understanding: before we can analyze anything, the mind must first synthesize raw sensory data into a coherent structure [18].

In my view, the modern humanities have suffered a catastrophic fracture between these two cognitive shears. By over-indexing on hyper-specialized analysis while letting the capacity for structural synthesis rust away, modern readers can dissect individual sentences in Milton, Shakespeare, or Hemingway, yet remain completely blind to the overarching, multi-layered architecture binding the entire work together.

A call to rebuild

Reviving the humanities requires abandoning purely subjective, sentiment-driven reading and restoring this symbolo-algebraic methodology. I have traced this exact structural encryption across a vast corpus of canonical works:

  • Classical Drama & Poetry: Euripides (Alcestis, Cyclops, Heracles’ Fury, Orestes, Rhesus), Sophocles (Philoctetes, Trachiniae), and Ovid (The Art of Love).
  • Medieval & Renaissance Canon: Le Morte d'Arthur, William Shakespeare (Hamlet, Macbeth, The Winter's Tale), and John Milton (Paradise Lost).
  • Modernist & Sacred Texts: T.S. Eliot (The Waste Land), James Joyce (Ulysses), Ernest Hemingway (The Old Man and the Sea), and the Bible.

Reconstructing this lost half of human cognition is too vast an undertaking for one person. Just as mathematics incentivizes breakthroughs through the Millennium Prize Problems and engineering drives innovation via the X-Prize, I am calling for dedicated, collaborative research teams to systematically decrypt and rebuild the rigorous foundations of the humanities. If you are keen to join me in this endeavour, please contact me at digangurung23@gmail.com. Cheers.

Notes & sources
  1. The Two Cultures: C.P. Snow, The Two Cultures and the Scientific Revolution (Cambridge University Press, 1959).↩
  2. Esoteric Writing: Leo Strauss, Persecution and the Art of Writing (Free Press, 1952).↩
  3. "Fit Though Few": John Milton, Paradise Lost (1667), Book VII, line 31; adapted from Horace, Odes, Book III, Ode 1.↩
  4. Maenads and Orpheus: Ovid, Metamorphoses, Book XI, lines 1–66; alluded to in Milton’s Paradise Lost, Book VII, lines 32–38.↩
  5. Renaissance Mathematical Poetics: S.K. Heninger Jr., Touches of Sweet Harmony: Pythagorean Cosmology and Renaissance Poetics (Huntington Library, 1974).↩
  6. Numerology in Paradise Lost: Alastair Fowler, Triumphal Forms: Structural Patterns in Elizabethan Poetry (Cambridge University Press, 1970) and Fowler’s annotated edition of Milton’s Paradise Lost (Longman, 1968).↩
  7. Nobel Prize Citation: The Nobel Prize in Literature 1954, awarded to Ernest Hemingway for The Old Man and the Sea (1952).↩
  8. Crucifixion Imagery: Ernest Hemingway, The Old Man and the Sea (Charles Scribner's Sons, 1952), p. 107.↩
  9. Thirty Pieces of Silver: The Bible, Gospel of Matthew 26:15.↩
  10. El Cobre Donation: Carlos Baker, Ernest Hemingway: A Life Story (Charles Scribner's Sons, 1969), documenting Hemingway's donation of his Nobel medal to Nuestra Señora de la Caridad del Cobre.↩
  11. Death of Judas: The Bible, Acts of the Apostles 1:18.↩
  12. The Iceberg Theory: Ernest Hemingway, Death in the Afternoon (Charles Scribner's Sons, 1932), Chapter 16.↩
  13. Jason and the Spartoi: Apollonius of Rhodes, Argonautica, Book III, lines 1354–1398.↩
  14. Shakespeare and Tudor/Stuart Politics: Stephen Greenblatt, Renaissance Self-Fashioning (University of Chicago Press, 1980); Jonathan Dollimore, Radical Tragedy (University of Chicago Press, 1984).↩
  15. The King's Men and Espionage Networks: Charles Nicholl, The Reckoning: The Murder of Christopher Marlowe (University of Chicago Press, 1992), detailing the overlap between Elizabethan playwrights, patrons, and Walsingham’s intelligence apparatus.↩
  16. Macbeth and James I: Garry Wills, Witches and Jesuits: Shakespeare's Macbeth (Oxford University Press, 1995).↩
  17. Analytic vs. Synthetic Judgments: Immanuel Kant, Critique of Pure Reason (1781; 2nd ed. 1787), Introduction, Section IV ("On the Difference Between Analytic and Synthetic Judgments").↩
  18. Transcendental Synthesis: Immanuel Kant, Critique of Pure Reason, Transcendental Analytic, §10 ("On the Pure Concepts of the Understanding, or Categories").↩